Most Valuable Rare Vintage Costume Jewelry: Top Picks and Expert Insights

costume jewelry

Vintage costume jewelry is a fascinating area of collecting, as it offers a window into the past while still having the potential to make a captivating statement today. With its rich history and diverse designs, many collectors and enthusiasts seek out rare and valuable pieces from the world of costume jewelry. As trends have changed over time, some costume jewelry items have become hard to find, further increasing their desirability and value.

Among the most sought-after pieces are those from renowned brands like Coro, Trifari, and Christian Dior, as well as unique and intricate designs that showcase the craftsmanship of their time. The value of these rare and valuable vintage costume jewelry items can vary greatly, depending on factors such as the designer, materials, and overall rarity.

Exploring the realm of vintage costume jewelry serves as both an aesthetic pleasure and an investment. Collectors appreciate the beauty and history of these pieces, while also anticipating the potential for their value to grow over time. Uncovering the treasures of this intricate world is a journey that can bring excitement and a sense of discovery for all who venture into it.

Most Valuable Vintage Costume Jewelry Brands

Miriam Haskell

Miriam Haskell’s design and craftsmanship are known for its intricate beadwork and detailed artistry, making the brand highly collectible. Her jewelry designs range from necklaces to brooches, with a variety of materials used, such as glass, rhinestones, and metal. Haskell’s unique designs and high-quality construction make her vintage costume jewelry a sought-after treasure among collectors and enthusiasts.


As a prominent costume jewelry brand, Trifari’s exquisite pieces showcase the company’s excellent craftsmanship and innovative designs. Featuring interesting styles and shapes, their vintage pieces are recognized for their elegance and creativity. From enamel to rhinestones, Trifari’s ensemble of materials and patterns has made it a top choice for vintage costume jewelry collectors.


Weiss costume jewelry is well-known for its use of high-quality Austrian rhinestones and premium craftsmanship. Their brilliantly cut and skillfully set stones contribute to the brand’s timeless appeal. Weiss designs range from dazzling necklaces to captivating brooches and earrings, making the brand’s vintage costume jewelry highly collectible and often rare to find.

Hattie Carnegie

Hattie Carnegie’s vintage costume jewelry is celebrated for its unique, artistic designs and high-quality materials. Her creations convey an air of sophistication and glamour, with pieces inspired by various time periods and styles, including Art Deco and Egyptian motifs. Carnegie’s attention to detail and innovative design concepts have made her brand a go-to for collectors and enthusiasts of vintage costume jewelry.

most expensive costume jewelry

Identifying Authentic Rare Vintage Costume Jewelry

Signs and Hallmarks

When trying to identify authentic rare vintage costume jewelry, the first place to look is for signs and hallmarks. These are stamps or engravings placed on the jewelry by the designer or manufacturer to indicate their authenticity. Some well-known costume jewelry designers include Coro, Trifari, and Eisenberg, whose pieces will often feature their respective logos or stamps. Keep in mind that not all vintage pieces will have hallmarks, so it’s crucial to look at other aspects of the piece as well.

Material Quality

The material quality is a significant factor in determining a costume jewelry piece’s value. High-quality vintage pieces may use rhinestones, glass, brass, and other materials that were popular at different times. Bakelite, for instance, is a fire-resistant, castable plastic used in colorful jewelry, particularly from the 1930s and ’40s, which can be worth $100 or more.


Well-crafted vintage costume jewelry is a treasure to collectors, and the level of detail and care put into a piece can impact its value. If the settings and clasps are of high quality and carefully applied, or if intricate metalwork is present, it may indicate a higher value piece. Look for jewelry that is well-made, with attention to detail, such as hand-set stones and well-constructed components.

Design and Style

The design and style of a piece of vintage costume jewelry are essential to its value and desirability. Unique and iconic pieces, such as those created during the Art Deco period or featuring a bold, distinctive design, can fetch higher prices than more generic or standard items. Some valuable designs include Coro’s Candelabra Pin (valued at $125) and the Crown Trifari Ruby Red Glass Poinsettia Flower Brooch from the Art Deco era, exemplifying sought-after vintage costume jewelry styles.

Factors Affecting the Value of Vintage Costume Jewelry


The condition of a piece of vintage costume jewelry is crucial in determining its value. Pieces with minimal wear and tear, intact plating or enamel, and well-preserved stones are generally more valuable than those with noticeable flaws or damage. Collectors tend to look for pieces in excellent or near-mint condition, as they are more likely to retain their value over time.


Rarity plays a significant role in the value of vintage costume jewelry. Pieces made by well-known designers such as Coco Chanel, Marion Haskell, Trifari, Monet, Weiss, Coro, Hobe, Bulgari, and Eisenburg are usually of high value due to their rarity and limited production. Likewise, jewelry made from early plastics like Bakelite and Celluloid is considered more valuable due to its scarcity.


Demand is another important factor that affects the value of vintage costume jewelry. Pieces that are highly sought after by collectors will generally be worth more than those with less demand. Factors that contribute to the demand for a specific piece can include the popularity of the designer, the uniqueness of the design, and the era in which the piece was produced.

Historical Significance

Historical significance can add to the value of vintage costume jewelry. Pieces with a rich history or story behind them may be more valuable than those without any known background. For example, jewelry worn by notable figures or featured in popular films can command higher prices. Additionally, pieces that represent specific trends or styles from a particular time period can also carry more value due to their cultural significance.

How to Determine the Value of Your Vintage Costume Jewelry

Professional Appraisal

One of the most reliable ways to determine the value of your vintage costume jewelry is through a professional appraisal. Finding a reputable and experienced appraiser is crucial in obtaining an accurate valuation. They will examine the piece, considering factors such as design, craftsmanship, materials, and age. Additionally, the appraiser will assess any damage or alterations that may affect the value. Remember to request a written appraisal report to document your jewelry’s value.

Online Research

Another approach to estimating your jewelry’s worth is by conducting online research. Start by examining the brand and design of your piece for authenticity. Check for specific markings or signatures that may indicate the maker or designer. Investigate the jewelry’s age, as this can significantly impact its value. Various online guides, forums, and collector communities can offer insights into identifying and valuing vintage jewelry. However, remember that online information can be subjective and may not always provide an accurate valuation.

Auction and Sale Records

Reviewing auction and sale records can give you an idea of the current market value for similar pieces of vintage costume jewelry. Websites such as eBay and public auction houses’ websites often have a record of completed sales, including the final selling price. Pay attention to factors like condition, rarity, and similarities to your piece when reviewing these records. While this method may be helpful in providing a general understanding of a piece’s value, it is important to remember that market trends can change, and the value of your jewelry may fluctuate over time.

Taking Care of Your Valuable Vintage Costume Jewelry

Caring for your valuable vintage costume jewelry is essential to preserve its beauty and value. Proper cleaning, maintenance, and storage are crucial aspects to consider.

Cleaning and Maintenance

  • Gentle Cleaning: Vintage costume jewelry can be fragile, so use a soft cloth to remove any dust or dirt. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials, as these can damage the finish or stones.
  • Polishing: For metal parts such as silver or gold-plated pieces, use a specially designed polishing cloth. Be gentle and avoid excessive rubbing, as this can wear away the plating.
  • Inspecting: Regularly inspect your jewelry for any damage, such as loose stones, broken clasps, or worn plating. Consult a professional jeweler for any necessary repairs to maintain the value of your vintage pieces.
  • Avoid Water and Humidity: Keep your jewelry away from water and moisture, as they can cause metals to tarnish or stones to become loose. Remove jewelry before performing any activities that may expose it to water or high humidity.

Storing and Displaying

  • Proper Storage: Store your valuable vintage costume jewelry in a cool, dry place. Use individual compartments or soft fabric pouches to prevent pieces from scratching or tangling with each other.
  • Organizing: Keep items organized by type, such as necklaces, bracelets, and earrings. This will make it easier to find a specific piece and avoid accidental damage while searching.
  • Avoid Direct Sunlight: Exposure to sunlight can cause colors to fade and metals to tarnish. Keep your jewelry in a dark place or use a storage case with a protective cover to shield it from the sunlight.
  • Displaying: If you choose to display your collection, consider using a glass case or a dedicated jewelry display, which will protect your pieces from dust and direct sunlight.

By following these guidelines, you can ensure that your valuable vintage costume jewelry remains in excellent condition for many years to come.

Selling and Investing in Rare Vintage Costume Jewelry

Investing in rare vintage costume jewelry can be a profitable venture if done with careful research and accurate valuations. As the market for these unique pieces continues to grow, the demand for high-quality and rare designs is on the rise.

One exceptional example of this is the brooch bought for 22 pounds (about $30) and sold the same day for 700 pounds (about $950) by Laura Clarice Webb, who runs London-based Clarice Jewellery. Such instances highlight the potential for significant profit in the world of vintage costume jewelry.

When selling and investing in this market, be aware of the most valuable and collectible brands, which include Crown Trifari, Lunch at the Ritz, Schreiner New York, and Christian Dior. Among these brands, you can find outstanding pieces like the Crown Trifari Ruby Red Glass Poinsettia Flower Brooch and the Christian Dior Musical Box Costume Brooch.

Understanding the specific characteristics of each decade’s designs can also enhance your knowledge and valuation skills. For example, the 1920s’ costume jewelry pieces typically included long earrings, narrow bracelets, and brooches made from white metals, colored glass stones, faux pearls, and marcasites.

When investing in vintage costume jewelry, ensure to verify each piece’s authenticity and condition, as these factors significantly impact an item’s value. Additionally, stay updated on market trends to determine the most sought-after items and the brands currently gaining popularity.

While dealing in vintage costume jewelry, always follow ethical practices and avoid misrepresented or plagiarized items. It’s not only essential for securing the trust of your buyers but also maintaining the integrity of this unique art form.

Written by Sebastian Hensiek

From Philadelphia, Sebastian is a fan of music, writing, art, and entertainment.