15 Foods You Should Never Order at a Diner

Tongpool Piasupun/Getty

Diners- Those beacons of comfort food, late-night eats, and questionable yet strangely charming décor. But hold on to your checkered mug of coffee because not everything on that greasy spoon menu is a golden oldie. Sometimes, venturing off the well-worn path of burgers and fries can lead you down a dark and flavorless alley. So, before you order that mystery meat surprise, let’s peek at 15 diner dishes that are best left untasted on the menu board.

Fish on Mondays

The OPMs/Facebook

Monday fish specials might seem tempting, but ordering fish at a diner on the first day of the week can be risky. Fish sitting around since Friday’s shipment can lose its freshness and flavor, leading to a less-than-stellar dining experience. Ditch the Monday fish blues by opting for other menu options instead.

Eggs Benedict with a Twist

Simon Attila Daniel/Getty

While Eggs Benedict is a classic brunch favorite, beware of extra creative variations at diners. Adding unconventional ingredients or sauces can result in a dish that is more confusing than delicious. Why take the risk? Have the traditional Eggs Benedict to escape culinary experiments gone wrong.

Mystery Meat Loaf

Blue Dahlia Bistro/Facebook

As a cherished comfort food, meatloaf can be satisfying. Still, diners sometimes serve mystery meatloaf, which leaves you questioning its origin. Order this dish only when the meat is clearly labeled to avoid surprises in your loaf.

Super-Sized Salads

narong wanthonglor/Getty

Beware of salads that promise to be meals in themselves. While the idea of greens and veggies sounds good, the reality might be a plate swimming in sugary dressings, fried toppings like croutons or chicken strips, and mountains of processed cheese. If you want a healthy option,  build your salad, skipping the creamy dressings and opting for a light vinaigrette and simple toppings.

The “All-Day Breakfast” Omelet

lauraag/Getty

Ordering an omelet packed with every ingredient under the sun might seem like a good idea, but it can lead to a mishmash of flavors and textures. Keep your omelet simple and focus on crucial ingredients for a more enjoyable breakfast experience.

Deep-Fried Everything

semenovp/Getty

Diners are known for their crispy delights, but deep-fried foods should be cautiously approached. Fried dishes can be heavy, greasy, and lacking in nutritional value. Go for grilled or baked options instead to lighten up your meal.

Questionable Seafood Pasta

Patryk_Kosmider/Getty

Seafood pasta at a diner can be hit or miss. Be wary of entrees with many different seafood types, as they may not all be fresh or perfectly cooked. Stick to more straightforward pasta dishes or seafood specials known for their quality.

The “Monster” Burger

Ezhukov/Getty

Piled high with multiple patties, cheese, bacon, and sauces, giant burgers may seem impressive. The reality is that they can also be a recipe for digestive disaster. For your health’s sake, ditch the monster for a more manageable burger size to avoid feeling overwhelmed and ensure you can taste all the flavors.

Overly Sauced Chicken Wings

Lizs.Kitchn/Facebook

Chicken wings are a favorite, but be cautious of those drowned in overly sweet, spicy, or gloppy sauces. Excess condiments can overpower the flavor of the tender protein and turn it into a messy ordeal. Pick wings with a balanced sauce-to-meat ratio for a finger-licking good experience.

Frozen Dinner Classics

Enio DePaz/Getty

Some diners offer frozen dinner classics like Salisbury steak or chicken pot pie. While convenient, these dishes can lack freshness and quality compared to homemade versions. Look for freshly prepared options or daily specials for a more satisfying meal. Even though microwaves work wonders in heating leftovers, they can’t always perform miracles with frozen dinner classics. 

Anything “Jumbo”

derketta/ Getty

Be cautious of menu items labeled “jumbo,” whether pancakes, sandwiches, or desserts. Although the portion size may seem appealing, jumbo dishes can be too much and lead to food waste. To avoid overeating, go for regular-sized portions or share them with a dining companion.

Vegetarian “Meat” Substitutes

Vladimir Mironov/Getty

Vegetarian options are great, but be wary of overly processed plant-based substitutes that mimic the taste and texture of meat. These substitutes can be high in sodium, preservatives, and artificial additives. For a healthier alternative, it’s best to go with plant-based foods made with whole ingredients.

Unidentifiable Casseroles

Clicknique/Getty

Casseroles can be comforting, but be cautious of ones that contain unidentifiable ingredients. Without clear labeling or descriptions, you might end up with a more baffling casserole than appetizing. Stick to familiar casserole meals or ask about the dish’s components before ordering.

The “All-You-Can-Eat” Anything

matthewennisphotography/Getty

We all love a good deal, but sometimes, “all you can eat” translates to “regret you will definitely eat.” Diner buffets often feature lukewarm, overcooked fare sitting out for who knows how long. Focus on quality over questionable quantity—your stomach (and taste buds) will thank you.

Anything Smothered in Cheese Sauce

from_my_point_of_view/Getty

Even though it is primarily delicious, be mindful of ones drowned in heavy cheese sauce. Its richness and heaviness can mask the flavors of the other ingredients and leave you feeling overly full. Choosing dishes with lighter cheese toppings or a side of dip is better.

Written by Lucas M